DEPARTMENTS’ OVERSIGHT OF ARM’S LENGTH BODIES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY

DEPARTMENTS’ OVERSIGHT OF ARM’S LENGTH BODIES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY
July 01 2016

The National Audit Office looked at four departments that oversee a large number of ALBs: Department for Business, Innovation & Skills, Ministry of Justice, Department for Environment, Department for Food & Rural Affairs, and Department for Culture, Media & Sport.

They found there is no collective understanding of what type of oversight is appropriate and cost effective for different types of arm’s-length bodies; the sector remains confused and incoherent. There is no single list of all ALBs across government nor a common understanding of when ALBs should be used, or what type of ALB is most appropriate for particular circumstances. Different departments define ALBs in different ways and some ALBs are uncertain about how they relate to their department’s objectives. The prevailing inconsistency hampers a coherent approach to overseeing ALBs that is consistent with their purpose, although the Cabinet Office is building on its Public Bodies Reform Programme and taking further steps to address this.

Amyas Morse, head of the National Audit Office, said:

“If one of the main reasons for having arm’s length bodies is to provide a zone of relative independence, the fact that oversight mechanisms focus predominantly on compliance and control means there is almost certainly room for improvement.”

View PCF’s response to the report here.

Browse by Category



Browse by Date



Events

PCF roundtable with Sir Jeremy Heywood, Head of the Civil Service

December 01 2017

PCF roundtable with Sir Jeremy Heywood, Head of the Civil Service

The PCF are delighted to be hosting another a roundtable event with Sir Jeremy Heywood, Head of the Civil Service, at the Institute for Government on…  more »

Cabinet Office Reviews with John Manzoni

January 12 2018

Cabinet Office Reviews with John Manzoni

Chief Executive of the Civil Service and Permanent Secretary for the Cabinet Office John Manzoni joins us to discuss the latest Cabinet Office thinking…  more »

Information rights and responsibilities, with the Information Commissioner

February 02 2018

Information rights and responsibilities, with the Information Commissioner

With the ever increasing quantity of sensitive material held by the public sector about citizens, there is a desire for people to know what is held…  more »